ADTA Member Steve Gerber's Firm Obtains Summary Judgment on Behalf of All Defendants

10/9/2017


ADTA member Steve Gerber, Schoeman Updike Kaufman LLP, Wayne, NJ, has reported that his firm received a summary on behalf of all defendant in the case of Butler v. Bridgehampton Fire District, et al (14-CV-1429 (JS) (AYS)) (EDNY).  The case is summarized below:

The plaintiff, a long-time treasurer and secretary for the Bridgehampton Fire District, alleged that the District, its Board of Fire Commissioners, and former Chair violated his constitutional rights when they eliminated his salary and terminated his benefits.  Specifically, the plaintiff alleged substantive due process violations, a bill of attainder claim, and First Amendment retaliation claims based on his alleged objections to the process by which the District attempted to sell a parcel of land.  The defendants presented evidence that their actions against the plaintiff were the result of significant job performance issues that included irregularities and deficiencies in the District’s finances, a belief that the plaintiff had engaged in forgery, and the plaintiff’s failure to report to work and carry out his duties for months. 
 
The District Judge granted summary judgment on all claims in favor of the defendants, adopting recommendations of the Magistrate Judge with respect to the bill of attainder, substantive due process, and First Amendment claim against the Board Chair.  With respect to the First Amendment claim against the District, the District Judge rejected the Magistrate Judge’s recommendation that the claim should proceed to trial and sustained the defendants’ objection, finding that the Mt. Healthy defense applied and  “a reasonable jury would have to conclude that the Board would have taken the same actions against Plaintiff in the absence of the protected speech.”
 


About ADTA

An ADTA prime membership is, in essence, a statement of the high regard in which defense trial attorneys are held by his or her peers in the defense trial bar of their city and state or province.